Post by chadouti on Mar 4, 2008 16:58:03 GMT
Aselam Alaikoum
I am an American convert, msulim for almost 3 years now. My husband is from Morocco and e have been married for over 2 years. About 6 months ago I began wearing hijab all the time. My husband has never been very supportive of this and sometimes he even asks me to take it off when we go out together. He thinks that as I live in a Western country where the hijab is not the norm that I draw more attention to myself and that it is better not to wear it. However he says this is my decision, it is betwee me and Allah, and he does not force me to do anything. My family is not supportive and even hostile toward the hijab snd I am obliged to take it off if I go anywhere with them. My husband's family has even criticised me for wearing them when we go to visit them in Morocco! My husband does not pray and I feel that I need more support but most of the muslim sisters I know are very extreme and strict and I do not feel comfortable around them either.
What I would like to know is, is the hijab strictly obligatory or are there situations where it is tolerated for a woman not to wear it? Wll a woman automatically be punished, go to hell for not wearing it, or would she be judged as an overall picture of the goods she does and her sins in order to make a decision? If I pray 5 times per day, dress modestly, fast and do good but don't wear hijab, can I be just as loved as a sister who does wear hijab?
I think that yes this is possible, however the fact that I already put hijab shows that I understand why it is important, so if I take it off maybe I am a hypocrite? I am struggling here very much and would like to know form an Islamic standpoint the implications of not wearing the hijab, of being a convert living in a Western country, and thinking that wearing it brings more harm than good and taking it off? I was a teacher and now can't teach in public schools because of hijab...
I have been suffering from severe depression, and my husband an I are worried, as I was severely depressed in my youth and attempted suicide at age 13. I have been feeling better for several years alhamdullilah but lately I have felt very isolated from my environment, and this especially since I have started wearing hiab and although I ask Allah in my prayers to help me with this I still feel that wearing the hijab aggravates my depression because I feel so distant from my family and strange in my envorinoment in the work field and in my community and that I will feel less depressed without hijab. I suffer from social anxiety, don't like to take medicationw hich only helps so much and counseling helps but I still feel that the hijab contribute much to my social anxiety.
Could depression and anxiety be considered a medical reason to not wear hijab? My depression and anxiety makes me question myself thinking oh you're just making excuses or that makes you a hypocrite what if later you want to wear it again? Then I say to myself no that's not true you have always had this problem and depression causes many problems in my marriage nad I don't see it should be bad if hijab causes more depression and anxietyand my husband prefers I don't wear it then maybe I should not. And if later in life I overcome these problems then you can start wearing it again, why not?
Is this logical? Is depression and anxiety a legitimate medical reason? Sorryfor the long explanation...
Shukran
I am an American convert, msulim for almost 3 years now. My husband is from Morocco and e have been married for over 2 years. About 6 months ago I began wearing hijab all the time. My husband has never been very supportive of this and sometimes he even asks me to take it off when we go out together. He thinks that as I live in a Western country where the hijab is not the norm that I draw more attention to myself and that it is better not to wear it. However he says this is my decision, it is betwee me and Allah, and he does not force me to do anything. My family is not supportive and even hostile toward the hijab snd I am obliged to take it off if I go anywhere with them. My husband's family has even criticised me for wearing them when we go to visit them in Morocco! My husband does not pray and I feel that I need more support but most of the muslim sisters I know are very extreme and strict and I do not feel comfortable around them either.
What I would like to know is, is the hijab strictly obligatory or are there situations where it is tolerated for a woman not to wear it? Wll a woman automatically be punished, go to hell for not wearing it, or would she be judged as an overall picture of the goods she does and her sins in order to make a decision? If I pray 5 times per day, dress modestly, fast and do good but don't wear hijab, can I be just as loved as a sister who does wear hijab?
I think that yes this is possible, however the fact that I already put hijab shows that I understand why it is important, so if I take it off maybe I am a hypocrite? I am struggling here very much and would like to know form an Islamic standpoint the implications of not wearing the hijab, of being a convert living in a Western country, and thinking that wearing it brings more harm than good and taking it off? I was a teacher and now can't teach in public schools because of hijab...
I have been suffering from severe depression, and my husband an I are worried, as I was severely depressed in my youth and attempted suicide at age 13. I have been feeling better for several years alhamdullilah but lately I have felt very isolated from my environment, and this especially since I have started wearing hiab and although I ask Allah in my prayers to help me with this I still feel that wearing the hijab aggravates my depression because I feel so distant from my family and strange in my envorinoment in the work field and in my community and that I will feel less depressed without hijab. I suffer from social anxiety, don't like to take medicationw hich only helps so much and counseling helps but I still feel that the hijab contribute much to my social anxiety.
Could depression and anxiety be considered a medical reason to not wear hijab? My depression and anxiety makes me question myself thinking oh you're just making excuses or that makes you a hypocrite what if later you want to wear it again? Then I say to myself no that's not true you have always had this problem and depression causes many problems in my marriage nad I don't see it should be bad if hijab causes more depression and anxietyand my husband prefers I don't wear it then maybe I should not. And if later in life I overcome these problems then you can start wearing it again, why not?
Is this logical? Is depression and anxiety a legitimate medical reason? Sorryfor the long explanation...
Shukran