Nuh Keller

[thc]

Assalamu alaikum,

Is not nuh keller a sunni?

wasalaam

[king786]

Assalamu 'Alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

I HAVE JUST READ THE ABOVE ARTICLE AND I FOUND THE BELOW STATEMENT OF SHAYK NUH VERY CONFUSING

Looking back, one cannot help wondering why Khalil Ahmad’s and Ashraf ‘Ali Thanwi’s own students and teachers and friends did not ask them, before their opponents asked them: When did any Islamic scholar ever compare the knowledge of the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) to the depraved, to the mad, or to animals—even to make a point? Few Muslims would suffer such a comparison to be made with their own father, let alone the Emissary of God (Allah bless him and give him peace). But while such words were indefensible breaches of proper respect, they were not kufr, because the intention behind them was not to insult the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace), but to defend Islam from what the writers viewed as a serious threat.


I WISH SHAYK NUH WOULD HAVE PAID MORE SERIOUS IMPORTANCE TO THE RESPECT OF PROPHET Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam AND STOP DEFENDING THE IGNORANT SO CALLED ISLAMIC DEOBANDI TOP SCHOLARS OTHERWISE THIS WILL MAKE HIS POSITION AS A SUNNI SCHOLAR VERY WEAK

[BlueLotus]

Someone of the rank of Huzoor Shaykh ul Islam Madani Mian need to refute Nuh. The Sunnis need to wake up to his Fitna and stop his Murids using our Masajid.

[BlueLotus]

a sunni brother has posted this recently, with direct scans from the books of the Deobandis. Will Keller now have the decency to take back his insults???

salam alaykum.
Mawlana Mahmood Hassan writes in his

Book : Al Jehd ul Muqil

Page : 41
Publisher : Maktaba Madniyya Urdu Bazar Lahore [ scan ]

that

Afaal e kabeeha(bad acts) ko Qudrat e Qadeema Haq Taala Shanahu say kiun kar khaarij keh saktay hain

Translation

"How can we say that it is out of the power of Allah that , He cannot perform bad acts.

Attached Image Attached Image

Mawlana Rashid Ahmed says in his fatawa
"
Page No 97 .. "Pas Sabit Howa Key Kizb Dakhil-e-Qudarat-e-Bari Ta'ala Wa Ala Hai"

Translation
" Hence , it is now established that to Lie is with in the possibility of Allah subhanahu wa taala"


Attached Image

Insha Allah, once yek Roza ( by Ismail dehalvee ) is posted that will make the matter very clear.

A small incidence from Arwahe Salasa , page 242.( A book deaing with the life of Deobandi scholars)

" One day after Fajr Salah mawalana Rafeeuddeen saheb (rh) invited Mawalana Mahmoodul Hasan saheb in his room( Inside darul uloom deoband). Mawlana (Mahmoodul Hasan) arrived and opened the door and entered inside . It was severe winter that time.

Mawalana Rafeeudeen saheb told to first examine his overcoat. When Mawalana (Mahmoodul Hasan ) saw this over coat it was wet. Mawlana Rafeeudeen told that just now Mawalana Nanatwee visited with his Physical body ( JASADE UNSAREE) and I was frightened so my overcoat became wet ( due to sweating). Mawalana Nanatvee ordered that Mahmood hasan should not indulge in this internal fight going among the teachers of Deoband. Mawalana Mahmood Hasan said "Hazrat I repent ( do tawbah on your hands) and I wil not speak anything after this in this on going internal fight"


Here Mawalana Qasim Nanatvee can come after his death and that too in physical form , just to resolve the fight in Deoband.

At other place we have seen Deobandi scholar saying" Allah can lie , but he will not lie" ( scan provided earlier)

Yet another place Mawlana Rashid Ahmed said in bis fatwa that to have a belief that Prophet had ilm e ghayb is a SHIRK.

It is upon the readers to decide how can a Mawlana can come after his death to resolve matter ,but prophet did not have knowledge of the unseen ( ilm e ghayb).

I would look for a sincere answer from any of the Deobandi Brother.

www.marifah.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=2533&st=45