Post by Fana fi Shaykh on Feb 17, 2008 11:53:36 GMT
Bismillahir Rahmanir Raheem
Assalamu 'Alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu
JAZZALLAHU ANNA SAYYEDINA MUHAMMADAN MA HUWA AHLAHU
BEDUM YEHI TO PAANCH HAIN MAQSUD-E-KAINAT
MUHAMMAD Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam O MURTUZA FATEMA HASAN O HUSSAIN
In the Shia books, Maula Ali alayhis 'salam is being described as somebody who would be abused and even beaten up by Khatoon-e-Jannat salamun alayha. (Naazubillah).
Maula Ali alayhis 'salam asked Salman Farsi Radi Allahu anhu to sell field that the beloved Prophet Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam had cultivated. Thus Salman Farsi Radi Allahu anhu sold it for twelve thousand dirhams and gave the money to Maula Ali alayhis 'salam.......thereafter Maula Ali alayhis 'salam gave 4004 dirhams out of the sum to a man who was poor and asked for money. This news spread in Madinah Shareef and one of the men from Ansar went to Syeda Fatima salamun alayha and told her of the incident. Thereafter, Maula Ali alayhis 'salam distributed the remaining sum too amongst the people to the extent that not a single dirham was left. Thereafter, Syeda Fatima salamun alayha asked Hazrat Ali alayhis 'salam , 'Did you sell my father's field?'.
He replied, 'Yes I have sold it'.
Bibi Fatima salamun alayha asked, 'Where is the money?'.
Maula Ali alayhis 'salam replied, 'I have spent it in the Path of Allah'.
In reply, Syeda Fatima salamun alayha replied, ' I am straving, our children are starving and you like us are starving and we do not have a single dirham in our possesion'. Upon saying this, Syeda Fatima salamun alayha grabbed Maula Ali alayhis 'salam by his clothes. Hazrat Ali alayhis 'salam said, 'O Fatima salamun alayha, let go of me'. Thereafter, Syeda Fatima salamun alayha said, 'I swear upon Allah, I shall not let you go until my father does justice between us.
Upon this, Jibrael alayhis 'salam descended and said to Rasool Allah Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam , that Allah Taalah sends Salaam upon you and Ali alayhis 'salam and says that tell Fatima salamun alayha that it is not permissible for her to hit Ali alayhis 'salam on his hands and to grab him by his clothes.
............Thereafter Rasool Allah Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam went to their house and repeated the command of Allah and Hazrat Fatima salamun alayha let go of Hazrat Ali alayhis 'salam and apologiesed........
Shia References:
1. Amaali Sudooq, Page 281, Al-Majlis-Al-Haadi Wa Sab'aoon
2. Jalal-ul-Ayoon, Volume I, Page 194
3. Anwar-e-Naumania, Volume I, Page 58
Naazubillah. Astaghfirullah. No Sunni can even imagine for the above to be remotely true. Not only does it potray Syeda Khatoon-e-Jannat salamun alayha as somebody who would be abusive towards her husband and held desires for worldly wealth but it is also equally misfitting for the excellence of the 'Lion of Allah' who never shyed away from any challenge nor returned from a battle anything but victorious.
Mojod-E-Kaaba Deen Mukammal Ali Ali
Paighambari Ka Shahid-E-Awwal Ali Ali
Vird-E-Zubaan Ehl-E-Zamana Ali Ali
Yakta-E-Roozgaar Yagana Ali Ali
Altaf-E-Bebadal Ka Khazana Ali Ali
Insaan Ki Azmatoon Ka Tarana Ali Ali
Assalamu 'Alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu
JAZZALLAHU ANNA SAYYEDINA MUHAMMADAN MA HUWA AHLAHU
BEDUM YEHI TO PAANCH HAIN MAQSUD-E-KAINAT
MUHAMMAD Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam O MURTUZA FATEMA HASAN O HUSSAIN
In the Shia books, Maula Ali alayhis 'salam is being described as somebody who would be abused and even beaten up by Khatoon-e-Jannat salamun alayha. (Naazubillah).
Maula Ali alayhis 'salam asked Salman Farsi Radi Allahu anhu to sell field that the beloved Prophet Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam had cultivated. Thus Salman Farsi Radi Allahu anhu sold it for twelve thousand dirhams and gave the money to Maula Ali alayhis 'salam.......thereafter Maula Ali alayhis 'salam gave 4004 dirhams out of the sum to a man who was poor and asked for money. This news spread in Madinah Shareef and one of the men from Ansar went to Syeda Fatima salamun alayha and told her of the incident. Thereafter, Maula Ali alayhis 'salam distributed the remaining sum too amongst the people to the extent that not a single dirham was left. Thereafter, Syeda Fatima salamun alayha asked Hazrat Ali alayhis 'salam , 'Did you sell my father's field?'.
He replied, 'Yes I have sold it'.
Bibi Fatima salamun alayha asked, 'Where is the money?'.
Maula Ali alayhis 'salam replied, 'I have spent it in the Path of Allah'.
In reply, Syeda Fatima salamun alayha replied, ' I am straving, our children are starving and you like us are starving and we do not have a single dirham in our possesion'. Upon saying this, Syeda Fatima salamun alayha grabbed Maula Ali alayhis 'salam by his clothes. Hazrat Ali alayhis 'salam said, 'O Fatima salamun alayha, let go of me'. Thereafter, Syeda Fatima salamun alayha said, 'I swear upon Allah, I shall not let you go until my father does justice between us.
Upon this, Jibrael alayhis 'salam descended and said to Rasool Allah Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam , that Allah Taalah sends Salaam upon you and Ali alayhis 'salam and says that tell Fatima salamun alayha that it is not permissible for her to hit Ali alayhis 'salam on his hands and to grab him by his clothes.
............Thereafter Rasool Allah Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam went to their house and repeated the command of Allah and Hazrat Fatima salamun alayha let go of Hazrat Ali alayhis 'salam and apologiesed........
Shia References:
1. Amaali Sudooq, Page 281, Al-Majlis-Al-Haadi Wa Sab'aoon
2. Jalal-ul-Ayoon, Volume I, Page 194
3. Anwar-e-Naumania, Volume I, Page 58
Naazubillah. Astaghfirullah. No Sunni can even imagine for the above to be remotely true. Not only does it potray Syeda Khatoon-e-Jannat salamun alayha as somebody who would be abusive towards her husband and held desires for worldly wealth but it is also equally misfitting for the excellence of the 'Lion of Allah' who never shyed away from any challenge nor returned from a battle anything but victorious.
Mojod-E-Kaaba Deen Mukammal Ali Ali
Paighambari Ka Shahid-E-Awwal Ali Ali
Vird-E-Zubaan Ehl-E-Zamana Ali Ali
Yakta-E-Roozgaar Yagana Ali Ali
Altaf-E-Bebadal Ka Khazana Ali Ali
Insaan Ki Azmatoon Ka Tarana Ali Ali
Can this be really true? There are many other incidents when the people of the house of Prophet Muhammad Salla Allahu ta'ala 'alayhi wa Sallam have spent days without eating anything but never returned a seeker empty handed from the doorstep, keeping this in mind, the above incident looks changed.
