kurbaani and halal requirements

[fatma]

Assalamu 'Alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

my dad usually does one sheep here on eid-ul-adha but this year didn't do so because the person doing the zabha was a deobandi and my dad said it wouldn't be counted.

so my question is if when doing a kurbaani it's done my deobandi then it's not counted then what about our day to day meat which we buy which could be made halal by deobandi's, sunni's etc. is that then permissable?

am very confused so would appreciate your answers.

[Musafir]

Dec 8, 2009 17:23:46 GMT fatma said:

Assalamu 'Alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

my dad usually does one sheep here on eid-ul-adha but this year didn't do so because the person doing the zabha was a deobandi and my dad said it wouldn't be counted.

so my question is if when doing a kurbaani it's done my deobandi then it's not counted then what about our day to day meat which we buy which could be made halal by deobandi's, sunni's etc. is that then permissable?

am very confused so would appreciate your answers.

If an ahle kitab (jew or christian)says the name of Allah and does zabiha according to sharia methods,this would be deemed halaal to consume according to classical scholars.

Yet if a deobandi(who is still within the fold of islam,despite being bud aqeeda) it will be haraam?

No offence to your respected father specifically,but i would just like to state that sunnis(infact the brelvi group of the subcontinant) are becoming too extremists in these masala's.
The age old excuse of all them being ghustak and us being Ashiqs does not really hold too much water either with the current bunch (on both sides), to be honest.

Please lets certain sunnis stop making a joke of themselves and of the other majority sunni too in the process.

Slaughter of any muslim(as long as kufr is not proven of him) is jaiz,period!

Nor are we obliged by shariah to go and hire private investigator to establish his exacts beliefs before we eat his zabiha meat.

The only differences we have with deobandis are in aqeeda not in fiqh madhab.